Could MicroStrategy Be on the Verge of Parting with Its Bitcoin Holdings?

How MicroStrategy’s BTC trade faces big institutional hurdles that could shake markets.

MicroStrategy has been Bitcoin's corporate poster child for half a decade. The company amassed nearly 650,000 BTC, about 3.1% of all Bitcoin ever mined. Its CEO, Michael Saylor, became the face of institutional Bitcoin adoption, famously proclaiming he would never sell their stash. But whispers are growing louder that MicroStrategy’s story might be shifting. Facing a critical MSCI decision in January 2026 and a crumbling stock premium that once fueled their Bitcoin buys, MicroStrategy might be forced into cash-raising moves that could include selling Bitcoin. What’s behind these risks? How real is the threat to Bitcoin’s price if MicroStrategy sells? Let’s break down the facts, risks, and what it means for crypto investors today.

Why MicroStrategy’s Bitcoin Holdings Matter

MicroStrategy isn’t just another crypto holder. Its 649,870 BTC dwarfs many sovereign and corporate coffers. This stash is worth billions. They funded it by issuing shares at a premium, allowing the firm to buy more Bitcoin — a flywheel fueling both Bitcoin and their stock price.

• Stock premium context: Investors once paid $2-$3 for each $1 of Bitcoin held by MicroStrategy. This “infinite money glitch” let the company issue shares at high prices, buy Bitcoin, then push the stock even higher.
• Current situation: The premium (called MNAV, multiple of net asset value) dipped below 1.0 in November 2025. MicroStrategy’s stock now trades below the value of its Bitcoin holdings. This kills the flywheel and means issuing more shares dilutes shareholders, not enriches them.

MSCI’s Index Decision: A Potential Game-Changer

MSCI is a major index provider whose ETFs manage trillions. They are considering excluding companies holding over 50% of assets in crypto from key equity indices. MicroStrategy, with 77% of its assets in Bitcoin, is the top candidate for exclusion.

• Decision timeline: Consultation ends Dec 31, 2025. Final decision expected Jan 15, 2026.
• Impact estimates:
  • If excluded from MSCI indices alone: $2.8 billion in forced MSTR stock selling.
  • If other major indices follow (NASDAQ 100, Russell): forced selling could reach $8.8 billion, 15–20% of MicroStrategy’s market cap.
• Price fallout: Forced selling would tank MSTR stock. Because MSTR and Bitcoin prices correlate closely, this could drag Bitcoin down — creating a negative feedback loop.

Debt and Dividend Pressure: Could MicroStrategy Be Forced to Sell Bitcoin?

Besides index pressure, MicroStrategy faces cash challenges: $54.3 million cash on hand versus $640 million in annual preferred stock dividends.

• Debt maturity: Most convertible notes mature no earlier than 2027. No immediate margin calls or forced repayments.
• Dividends: Dividends can be suspended by the board, which is controlled heavily by Saylor (~42% voting power).
• CEO stance: Saylor publicly denied rumors of selling Bitcoin and said the company is accelerating purchases.

This suggests forced Bitcoin liquidation is unlikely soon, but the dividend burden remains a concern, potentially incentivizing difficult decisions.

How Much Does MicroStrategy Really Move Bitcoin’s Market?

Despite its size, MicroStrategy’s Bitcoin buying averages just 3.3% of weekly Bitcoin trading volume. Correlation between MicroStrategy buys and BTC price is low (~0.25 to 0.28).

• Bitcoin trades billions daily; MicroStrategy is a big whale but not the ocean.
• Other players now own large Bitcoin reserves: corporations, ETFs, countries.
• MicroStrategy once broke institutional adoption ice, but now Bitcoin’s ecosystem is mature.

Answer Box: Could MicroStrategy selling Bitcoin crash the crypto market?

MicroStrategy’s Bitcoin holdings are large, but their weekly purchase volume averages just 3.3% of all Bitcoin trading. While forced selling of MSTR stock due to MSCI exclusion might impact MicroStrategy’s stock price and create short-term volatility, Bitcoin is a global market with many large holders. Past shocks (FTX, Mt. Gox) show Bitcoin can absorb large sales though with volatility. So, a crash triggered solely by MicroStrategy selling is unlikely, but short-term volatility is probable.

Risks: What Could Go Wrong?

• MSCI excludes MicroStrategy: Massive forced selling of MSTR shares could plunge stock price, dampening sentiment toward Bitcoin and causing a temporary price spiral.
• Collapse of the stock premium: Without high stock valuations, MicroStrategy loses its key lever for buying more Bitcoin, drying up a major institutional buyer.
• Dividend and cash stress: $640 million dividend obligations with little cash could pressure management to consider asset sales or dividend cuts—each carrying risks.
• Precedent effect: MSCI rules may scare other companies off from holding crypto on their balance sheets, slowing broader corporate Bitcoin adoption.

Data Callout: MicroStrategy’s Stock Trades Below BTC Value

• MNAV fell to ~0.87 in November 2025, meaning buying MicroStrategy stock costs less than the Bitcoin assets it holds.
• This undercuts the “infinite money glitch” that let MicroStrategy raise cash by issuing shares.

What Does This Mean for Investors?

• Watch MSCI’s January 2026 decision closely; it’s a binary event with billions on the line.
• Don’t expect MicroStrategy to backstop Bitcoin with aggressive buys while their stock trades at a discount.
• Bitcoin’s fundamentals remain strong — network security and global adoption support price.
• A potential “uncoupling” from MicroStrategy might be healthier longer-term, removing a systemic risk.

Actionable Summary

• MicroStrategy holds 3.1% of all Bitcoin, making it a major institutional player.
• MSCI’s upcoming decision could force billions in MSTR stock sales, pressuring Bitcoin prices.
• The company’s stock now trades below Bitcoin value, stopping their previous capital-raising model.
• Debt maturities are distant, but dividend obligations are high and could influence corporate moves.
• Bitcoin’s market is large and diverse; MicroStrategy is important but no longer dominant in driving price.

If you want deeper insight into institutional flows and what they mean for your crypto portfolio, get the full playbook, timely alerts, and model portfolios in today’s Wolfy Wealth PRO brief. Navigate volatility with a strategic edge.

FAQ

Q1: Why does MSCI’s index decision matter for Bitcoin?
A: MSCI manages indices tracked by passive funds. Excluding MicroStrategy would force large-scale MSTR stock selling, pressuring Bitcoin markets due to the close correlation.

Q2: What is the MNAV, and why does it matter?
A: MNAV is the multiple of net asset value — how the stock price compares to Bitcoin held. Above 1 suggests premiums allowing capital raises; below 1 means dilution risk and kills MicroStrategy’s stock-for-Bitcoin flywheel.

Q3: Could MicroStrategy sell Bitcoin against Saylor’s promise?
A: It’s unlikely but not impossible. Debt maturities are far off, but dividend pressures and cash needs could force difficult choices. Saylor currently denies sale rumors.

Q4: Does MicroStrategy’s selling cause Bitcoin price crashes?
A: Historically, MicroStrategy’s buying represented only ~3.3% of weekly Bitcoin volume. While their moves impact sentiment, Bitcoin’s global liquidity and many holders dilute this effect.

Q5: What should investors watch next?
A: The MSCI decision announcement on Jan 15, 2026, and MicroStrategy’s quarterly reports on cash and dividend status are key to monitoring risks.

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes and does not constitute financial advice. Cryptocurrency investments carry risk, and past performance is not indicative of future results.

By Wolfy Wealth - Empowering crypto investors since 2016

Subscribe to Wolfy Wealth PRO


Disclosure: Authors may be crypto investors mentioned in this newsletter. Wolfy Wealth Crypto newsletter, does not represent an offer to trade securities or other financial instruments. Our analyses, information and investment strategies are for informational purposes only, in order to spread knowledge about the crypto market. Any investments in variable income may cause partial or total loss of the capital used. Therefore, the recipient of this newsletter should always develop their own analyses and investment strategies. In addition, any investment decisions should be based on the investor's risk profile