As the Federal Reserve’s September policy meeting approaches, market consensus largely anticipates a rate cut to stimulate growth and ease borrowing costs. However, what if the Fed decides to do the unexpected and keeps interest rates high? Let’s dive into the implications of such a scenario and why Fed Chair Jerome Powell might stick to a steadfast, cautious monetary stance despite mounting pressures.
The Market’s Expectations and the “Devil’s Advocate” View
Most investors and economists expect the Fed to lower rates in September, responding to signs that inflation is cooling and the economy is slowing. Yet, playing devil’s advocate—acknowledging the possibility the Fed holds firm—helps prepare for the less optimistic but realistic outcomes.
Jerome Powell’s recent speech at the annual Jackson Hole Economic Symposium provided mixed signals. While there were hints of optimism—highlighting inflation moving closer to the 2% target and a softening labor market—Powell’s tone was measured and cautious. He offered no firm promise of rate cuts, maintaining that any such moves would depend heavily on forthcoming economic data.
Inflation: Not Quite Out of the Woods
The Fed’s main concern remains inflation. Though overall inflation figures like the Consumer Price Index (CPI) have settled somewhat, staying just below 3%, key inflation indicators tell a less comforting story:
- The Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) price index—preferred by the Fed—shows inflation holding at around 2.7%, trending upward since April.
- Core CPI, excluding food and energy, recently hit 3.1%, marking a significant monthly increase.
- Producer Price Index (PPI), which measures input costs, surged from 2.5% to 3.2%, suggesting that consumer prices could rise again soon.
- The ISM services prices paid index—a leading indicator closely tracking CPI with a three-month lead—is signaling potential inflation reacceleration above 4% in coming months.
These figures imply inflation remains "sticky," resisting quick declines despite tightening policies. The Fed is therefore cautious about prematurely loosening monetary policy.
Labor Market: A Mixed Bag
The Fed has a dual mandate: to maintain price stability and maximize employment. Labor market dynamics often influence whether the Fed leans toward easing or tightening.
In recent months, employment data have softened:
- July payroll growth was only 73,000, well below expectations.
- June and May payrolls were revised sharply downward, indicating slower hiring.
- Yet, unemployment remains relatively low at 4.2%, and average hourly wages increased 3.9% year-over-year.
This combination—a slow but steady labor market with rising wages—suggests the economy hasn’t tipped into recession, but inflation risks linked to wage growth persist.
Additional nuance lies in federal employment, which has been declining for months due to ongoing job cuts—though the full impacts are not yet fully reflected in broader statistics.
The Fed’s New Monetary Framework: Commitment to 2% Inflation
Powell highlighted the Fed’s commitment to a "cleaner," more disciplined inflation-targeting framework. Unlike prior approaches where some inflation overshoot was tolerated to boost employment, the current stance is laser-focused on achieving and maintaining inflation at 2%.
This shift suggests the Fed might prioritize controlling inflation even if it means keeping rates elevated longer, rather than cutting prematurely—especially if inflation risks re-accelerate.
Perspectives From Fed Officials: Divided Opinions
Within the Fed, opinions diverge. Some regional Fed presidents express caution about cutting rates soon:
- St. Louis Fed President James Bullard has left open a "crack in the door" for cuts if data supports.
- Kansas City Fed President Esther George and others urge more data before considering easing, citing persistent inflation.
- Fed speeches emphasize data-dependence over predetermined policy moves.
Potential Consequences of the Fed Maintaining High Rates
If the Fed sticks to higher rates through September and beyond, here’s what might unfold:
- Short-term market volatility: Investors generally prefer rate cuts to stimulate growth. Delaying cuts could lead to negative equity market reactions initially.
- Slower economic growth: Higher borrowing costs may dampen consumer spending and business investment, potentially slowing GDP.
- Inflation control: Persistently high rates could help curb inflation’s stubborn upward trends, improving purchasing power and price stability long term.
- Labor market impact: Maintaining rates might eventually lead to increased unemployment if businesses slow hiring or lay off workers due to higher costs.
- Cryptocurrency and alternative markets: Traders in crypto markets should brace for volatility as monetary policy tightness can affect risk assets broadly.
Preparing for the Unknown
While the market is eager for a rate cut, it’s crucial to consider the possibility that Powell and the Fed "stick to their guns." Being prepared for this scenario means closely watching upcoming inflation readings (CPI, PPI, PCE) and labor market data (jobs reports, wage growth) due in the weeks ahead.
Understanding the Fed’s cautious stance allows traders and investors alike to avoid being blindsided and adjust their strategies according to the evolving economic reality.
In Summary:
Jerome Powell’s September Fed meeting may defy expectations of rate cuts if inflation shows resilience and economic indicators suggest caution. The Fed's fresh commitment to a strict 2% inflation target, combined with mixed labor data and signals of sticky inflation, may keep interest rates elevated longer. Considering this possibility is essential to navigating markets in the months ahead.
By Wolfy Wealth - Empowering crypto investors since 2016
Subscribe to Wolfy Wealth PRO
Disclosure: Authors may be crypto investors mentioned in this newsletter. Wolfy Wealth Crypto newsletter, does not represent an offer to trade securities or other financial instruments. Our analyses, information and investment strategies are for informational purposes only, in order to spread knowledge about the crypto market. Any investments in variable income may cause partial or total loss of the capital used. Therefore, the recipient of this newsletter should always develop their own analyses and investment strategies. In addition, any investment decisions should be based on the investor's risk profile.
