Why frequent trading can erode your returns — and how a patient strategy often wins in the long run
Investors often believe that actively trading will lead to greater profits. But data from a major study analyzing 66,000 households suggests otherwise. Between 1991 and 1996, those who traded more frequently typically earned lower returns than the market average. This article breaks down why excessive trading can hurt your portfolio and why patience might be your best wealth-building ally.
Why More Trading Didn’t Mean More Profit — Key Findings from the Study
A study by Brad Barber and Terrance Odean examined trading behavior among thousands of investors with accounts at major brokerages. The dataset covered five years, providing a robust picture of how trading frequency impacted returns.
Here are the headline takeaways:
- Active traders replaced their entire portfolios roughly every four months, resulting in an annual turnover rate of 250%. For example, someone holding Apple and Coca-Cola stock would sell all shares and buy completely different stocks within that short timeframe.
- These highly active investors earned an average annual return of 11.4% during the study period.
- Meanwhile, the broader stock market index returned 17.9% annually in the same timeframe.
- On average, all investors – active and passive combined – had a portfolio turnover of about 75% per year and earned slightly less than the market index.
- The more transactions an investor made, the lower their returns, losing about 6.5 percentage points annually compared to a simple buy-and-hold strategy tracking the index.
This evidence highlights a clear pattern: trading too often tends to reduce profits due to fees, poor timing, and behavioral biases.
What This Means: Patience Is a Powerful Investment Tool
Frequent buying and selling costs money — commissions, bid-ask spreads, and taxes add up. But more importantly, actively trading pushes investors to make decisions based on emotions or short-term market noise rather than fundamentals.
Here’s why patience often wins:
- Compounded Growth: Staying invested over longer periods allows gains to multiply exponentially.
- Lower Costs: Fewer trades mean fewer fees and reduced tax consequences.
- Reduced Mistakes: Waiting avoids impulsive decisions like panic selling or chasing fads.
- Less Stress: Less time and energy spent monitoring daily market swings.
Research suggests that a diversified, well-constructed portfolio that is rebalanced occasionally typically outperforms most active strategies.
Answer Box: Why Does Frequent Trading Lower Investment Returns?
Frequent trading lowers returns mainly due to increased transaction costs, taxes, and behavioral errors. Active traders often sell winners too early or buy based on short-term trends, missing out on long-term compounded gains. The 1991–1996 study of 66,000 investors found those with higher turnover earned significantly less than the market index.
Data Callout: Turnover Rate and Returns (1991–1996 Study)
| Investor Type | Annual Turnover Rate | Annual Return (%) |
|---|---|---|
| Highly Active Traders | 250% | 11.4 |
| Average Investors | 75% | ~ less than 17.9 |
| Market Index | N/A | 17.9 |
This table shows that investors who traded less frequently tended to earn higher returns, with the market index outperforming most.
Risks & What Could Go Wrong with Patience
While a buy-and-hold approach generally outperforms excessive trading, it’s not risk free:
- Market downturns can cause significant paper losses that test investor discipline.
- Holding losing positions for too long without reassessing fundamentals can tie up capital.
- Ignoring major shifts (like business model changes or fraud) can hurt returns.
- Overconcentration in a few stocks undermines diversification benefits.
Prudent investors combine patience with informed monitoring and periodic portfolio rebalancing.
Actionable Summary
- Trading too often typically lowers portfolio returns due to costs and poor timing.
- The 1991–1996 study of 66,000 investors showed high turnover traders earned about 6.5% less annually than the market.
- Patience allows for compounding, cost savings, and calmer decision-making.
- A diversified, balanced portfolio rebalanced occasionally is a proven path toward wealth growth.
- Always reassess holdings to avoid holding poor performers indefinitely.
For deeper insights, real-time alerts, and tailored models to help you build wealth patiently yet proactively, get the full playbook and entries in today’s Wolfy Wealth PRO brief.
FAQ
Q: Why do frequent trades reduce investment returns?
A: Higher commissions, taxes, and emotional decision-making lead to suboptimal timing and costs, reducing net gains.
Q: How often should I rebalance my portfolio?
A: Generally, once or twice a year is enough to maintain asset allocation without incurring excessive costs.
Q: Does this mean I should never trade?
A: Not necessarily. Active trading can be justified with strong research or to adjust for significant life changes — but frequent impulsive trades usually hurt returns.
Q: What is turnover rate in investing?
A: Turnover rate measures the percentage of a portfolio replaced within a year. Higher turnover often means more trading costs.
Q: Is buy-and-hold always better than active trading?
A: While it often outperforms most retail investors, no strategy is perfect. The key is disciplined investing matched to your goals and risk tolerance.
Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and is not financial advice. Investing involves risks including loss of principal.
By Wolfy Wealth - Empowering crypto investors since 2016
Subscribe to Wolfy Wealth PRO
Disclosure: Authors may be crypto investors mentioned in this newsletter. Wolfy Wealth Crypto newsletter, does not represent an offer to trade securities or other financial instruments. Our analyses, information and investment strategies are for informational purposes only, in order to spread knowledge about the crypto market. Any investments in variable income may cause partial or total loss of the capital used. Therefore, the recipient of this newsletter should always develop their own analyses and investment strategies. In addition, any investment decisions should be based on the investor's risk profile
