Navigating the cryptocurrency market is often likened to stepping into a ring with one of the world’s fiercest opponents. As legendary boxer Mike Tyson once said, "Everyone has a plan until they get punched in the face." This perfectly captures the reality of investing in crypto — prices can surge or plummet unexpectedly, and these swings can happen far more rapidly or slowly than anticipated. With such volatility, it’s crucial to have a clear, thoughtful strategy for when to take profits or cut losses. Here’s a step-by-step guide to help you understand the dynamics at play and make more informed decisions about cashing out your cryptocurrency holdings.
Understanding the Crypto Market Cycle
The first step in determining when to cash out is to identify where we currently stand in the crypto market cycle. This cycle is generally understood as a four-year pattern comprising roughly 1 to 2 years of a bull market followed by 2 to 3 years of a bear market.
At present, we are approaching the end of a bull market phase. Bitcoin has already captured the bulk of its gains, and capital is beginning to flow into altcoins, starting with larger ones like Ethereum and Solana. Historically, when Ethereum outperforms Bitcoin, it signals a rotation into altcoins, with others expected to follow.
This stage in the cycle means your strategy for cashing out should differ depending on whether you primarily hold Bitcoin or altcoins. If you're a Bitcoin holder, it may be wise to start taking profits now, assuming you haven’t done so already. For altcoin holders, however, it might be premature to sell or cut losses as many altcoins usually gain momentum after Bitcoin’s peak.
Tailoring Your Strategy to Your Personal Circumstances
Deciding when to cash out isn’t just about market timing; it’s also about your individual profile. Factors like your investment time horizon, level of wealth, risk tolerance, and tax implications all play critical roles.
- Long-term, wealthy, high-risk tolerance, low-tax jurisdiction: In this scenario, holding Bitcoin and taking minimal profits—or none at all—may be optimal since Bitcoin’s value tends to increase over the long term due to its limited supply.
- Short-term, less wealthy, low-risk tolerance, high-tax jurisdiction: Here, frequent profit-taking and cutting losses might be wise, as enduring extended volatility could be difficult, and tax considerations may impact returns.
Risk tolerance can be self-assessed by asking yourself: If the price of a crypto asset drops by 90%, do you react emotionally? And if it rises 90%, are you overly exuberant? If “yes,” your risk tolerance might be low, which underscores the importance of managing your emotions during volatile swings.
Accepting Imperfection: When to Sell Early or Late
It’s important to recognize that perfectly timing a complete exit from crypto holdings is nearly impossible. The key question then becomes: would you prefer to be too early or too late in selling?
- If holding Bitcoin near cycle peak, you’re more likely to be too late than too early.
- For altcoins, the inverse may hold true.
Understanding your preference and the crypto types you hold can guide you in setting realistic profit-taking or stop-loss targets.
Practical Guidance on Taking Profits and Cutting Losses
Cutting Losses on Altcoins
Altcoins often trade within specific price ranges. For example, Aptos (APT) has historically fluctuated between approximately $4 and $15-$20. Currently trading near the bottom of this range, it may either bounce back or fall further if it breaks below this support. While it’s impossible to predict with certainty, history indicates altcoins tend to rally strongly near the end of bull markets.
Using technical indicators like Bollinger Bands on monthly charts helps identify key resistance levels, which can inform your profit-taking strategy. For instance, a rise towards the middle Bollinger Band around $8 for APT represents a potential selling point.
Taking Profits Gradually
Rather than selling all holdings upon hitting the first resistance, a staggered approach often suits altcoins well. Using Avalanche’s AVAX as an example, consider taking partial profits at $30, $40, and $55, while leaving the rest invested for potential further gains.
Ethereum and Solana present a different picture: both are at or near multi-year highs with limited resistance above current levels except their all-time highs. In these cases, setting take-profit orders just below key psychological levels—like $7,000-$8,000 for ETH or $500-$600 for Solana—can help you exit more strategically.
Cutting Losses with Confidence
When it comes to losses, a similar strategy applies. Unless a coin is effectively "dead" (no active development, dwindling community, or adverse events such as hacks), there’s reasonable potential for recovery within the investment cycle. Look for signs of ongoing activity and use technical resistance and support levels to decide when to reduce exposure. Investors can scale out slowly rather than panic-sell at a steep loss.
What to Do With Your Gains or Losses
After cashing out, a new challenge arises: where to put your capital? It’s tempting to jump into the hottest asset, be it another crypto or a booming stock sector. However, aligning your decisions with broader market cycles—crypto and macroeconomic alike—can prevent transferring risk rather than mitigating it.
Stablecoins and tokenized gold may seem like safe havens but come with their own counterparty risks, especially in bear markets. Physical gold or Bitcoin themselves tend to be safer bets with fewer risks of collapse due to external factors.
Careful evaluation of any asset's inherent risks, the macroeconomic landscape, and your personal goals is essential before reinvesting. Remember, the goal is preserving and growing your gains, not inadvertently exposing them to greater downside.
Final Thoughts
Deciding when to cash out cryptocurrency requires a nuanced blend of understanding market cycles, assessing your risk tolerance and personal situation, and using technical tools to set realistic exit strategies. Whether you hold Bitcoin or altcoins, approaching your selling decisions with a clear plan grounded in data and tempered by self-awareness can improve your chances of success in this notoriously volatile market.
Always remember: the right moment to cash out is as individual as your financial journey. Patience, informed choices, and emotional discipline remain your best allies in unlocking the secrets to profitable crypto investing.
If you enjoyed this overview and want to dive deeper into market cycles, altcoin strategies, or managing crypto profits, stay tuned for more content tailored to enhance your investing acumen.
By Wolfy Wealth - Empowering crypto investors since 2016
Subscribe to Wolfy Wealth PRO
Disclosure: Authors may be crypto investors mentioned in this newsletter. Wolfy Wealth Crypto newsletter, does not represent an offer to trade securities or other financial instruments. Our analyses, information and investment strategies are for informational purposes only, in order to spread knowledge about the crypto market. Any investments in variable income may cause partial or total loss of the capital used. Therefore, the recipient of this newsletter should always develop their own analyses and investment strategies. In addition, any investment decisions should be based on the investor's risk profile.
